Jump to content

Disclaimer



Photo
- - - - -

The Four Ivorocono Girls


  • Please log in to reply
22 replies to this topic

#1 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 05 March 2018 - 06:37 PM

Hello,

I would appreciate any and all comments/critiques on draft one of this query. Also, if anyone has better comp titles, please let me know. Feel free to leave a link to your post in the comments and I'll provide critiques as well.

 

TRY NUMBER 3 IS POST #13

 

 

QUERY:
Theo Ivorocono is not too bothered with raising his four daughters. His only goal is finishing the world-changing experiment he started with his deceased wife. This task leaves little time for parenting.

His teenage daughters are left to raise themselves in Fritica, a country on the verge of a second civil war. When one sister gets the chance of a lifetime, her only choice is to go to the East, the enemy side. This proposal starts a chain of events which separates the sisters for the first time in their lives.

With one sister seduced to the East, another sister leaves to study at a monastery. The monastery houses a fortune teller with the secret to finishing Theo's experiment. Theo's oldest daughter joins the military to financially support the family; and his second oldest is left alone at home where she wreaks havoc with an underground gang of smugglers and thieves.

Theo sees opportunity in each of their situations. Even if they don't respect him, his daughters can help find the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Fritica's fate and the end of Theo's experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separating at such a tumultuous time means the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.

THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words. Set in a futuristic Antarctica, the story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. This story is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS.

[Personal Bio]

Thank you for your time and consideration.



#2 RosieSkye

RosieSkye

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 724 posts
  • Literary Status:agented
  • LocationUS Southwest

Posted 05 March 2018 - 07:10 PM

Hello,

 

I would appreciate any and all comments/critiques on draft one of this query. Also, if anyone has better comp titles, please let me know. Feel free to leave a link to your post in the comments and I'll provide critiques as well.

 

 

QUERY:

Theo Ivorocono is not too bothered with raising his four daughters. His only goal is finishing the world-changing experiment he started with his deceased wife. This task leaves little time for parenting.

 

His teenage daughters are left to raise themselves in Fritica, a country on the verge of a second civil war. When one sister gets the chance of a lifetime, her only choice is to go to the East, the enemy side. This proposal starts a chain of events which separates the sisters for the first time in their lives.

 

With one sister seduced to the East, another sister leaves to study at a monastery. The monastery houses a fortune teller with the secret to finishing Theo's experiment. Theo's oldest daughter joins the military to financially support the family; and his second oldest is left alone at home where she wreaks havoc with an underground gang of smugglers and thieves.

 

Theo sees opportunity in each of their situations. Even if they don't respect him, his daughters can help find the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Fritica's fate and the end of Theo's experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separating at such a tumultuous time means the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.

 

THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words. This story is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS.

 

[Personal Bio]

 

Thank you for your time and consideration.

 

 

This sounds interesting, but there are two things here that leave me scratching my head.  One, I don't have any idea where or when this story takes place.  You mention magic and fantasy at the very end, but before that I don't know if Fritica and the East are in some other realm, or are fictional places in the real world.  I'd state up front that this is fantasy, or be clearer about your setting.  

 

Two, if this is YA, your query needs focus on a character(s) in that age range.  The characters that are going to speak to a YA audience are the daughters, not the father.  You're using him as the anchor for your query, around which the four daughters revolve - but unfortunately that's not going to do much to sell a YA.  Right now the daughters are just nameless, faceless figures - "one sister," "oldest daughter," "second oldest," etc.  You need to bring them to life, and let the agent connect with the characters that your core audience is going to be most interested in.  I'd chose the most prominent of the girls and focus the query around her, and then work her sisters into the query that way.

 

Good luck! 



#3 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 05 March 2018 - 07:22 PM

This sounds interesting, but there are two things here that leave me scratching my head.  One, I don't have any idea where or when this story takes place.  You mention magic and fantasy at the very end, but before that I don't know if Fritica and the East are in some other realm, or are fictional places in the real world.  I'd state up front that this is fantasy, or be clearer about your setting.  

 

Two, if this is YA, your query needs focus on a character(s) in that age range.  The characters that are going to speak to a YA audience are the daughters, not the father.  You're using him as the anchor for your query, around which the four daughters revolve - but unfortunately that's not going to do much to sell a YA.  Right now the daughters are just nameless, faceless figures - "one sister," "oldest daughter," "second oldest," etc.  You need to bring them to life, and let the agent connect with the characters that your core audience is going to be most interested in.  I'd chose the most prominent of the girls and focus the query around her, and then work her sisters into the query that way.

 

Good luck! 

 

@RosieSkye

 

Hello,

 

Thank you for your response! I agree with your first statement. I'll try to make that more clear in the next draft. It is set in a futuristic Antarctica so I'll add that in.

 

I also agree with your second comment. But, since each sister is given equal time throughout the story, it's hard for me to single one out. I'll have to think on how I can do that in an effective way.

 

Thank you again for taking the time to comment! If you have a post and want me to critique it let me know!



#4 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 06 March 2018 - 05:19 PM

Try #2:

 

 

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters and the last to know she's being sent away for the summer. Most importantly, the last hope for her parent's world-changing experiment. Skye learns she'll spend the summer studying at a monastery which houses a fortune teller with the answers they need. 
 
Not only is Skye leaving, but every sister will be separated for the first time in their lives -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war. Her fifthteen-year-old sister is given an opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. Their oldest sister joins the military to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves.
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death, he expects help finding the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.
 
Set in a futuristic Antarctica, this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
[Short Bio]
 
Thank you for your time and consideration.


#5 Raptor

Raptor

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 7 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting, published, unagented
  • LocationUS Northeast

Posted 06 March 2018 - 10:19 PM

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters,  and the last to know she's going away, being sent away for the summer, and the last hope for her parent's world-changing experiment. Skye learns she'll go to  spend the summer studying at a monastery where a  which houses a fortune teller seer holds the answers they (they who, her family?) need.  (Very good opening.  I collapsed it, believing this shorter, direct version grabs my attention.  I struck the words -- "for the summer," "world-changing," "which houses" -- that distracted me or raised questions as soon as I hit them.  You might consider another term for "fortune teller" (seer?) 

 
Not only is Skye leaving, but all four every sisters will be separated for the first time in their lives -- just when Antarctica faces is threatened by a second civil war. Her fifthteen-year-old sister is offered given a rare opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. Their oldest sister joins the military (which military--enemy or friendly?) to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves.
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death, he expects help finding the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again. (I like how this comes together.  My one question is about dad.  Is he good or bad, or is that the plot twist? You might signal that somehow by either saying the dad is evil or perhaps not. 
 
Set in a futuristic Antarctica, this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
Jane - This a very good query.  I'm not a futuristic/sci-fi fan, but you grabbed my attention and held it.  Perhaps an agent who specializes in sci-fi would feel differently.  But you should take some comfort knowing that you had a "non-believer" hooked in your story.  Best of luck and hope you you land a deal.   --- Raptor.


#6 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 07 March 2018 - 08:12 AM

Thank you so much!! I appreciate every comment/suggestion and will make those changes.

#7 AutumnL

AutumnL

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 34 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting, unagented
  • LocationUS Midwest
  • Publishing Experience:Nada

Posted 07 March 2018 - 08:55 AM

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters and the last to know she's being sent away for the summer. Most importantly, the last hope for her parent's world-changing experiment. Skye learns she'll spend the summer studying at a monastery which houses a fortune teller with the answers they need. (I like the opening,   
 
Not only is Skye leaving, but every sister will be separated for the first time in their lives (Maybe change it to something along the lines of Skye's leaving also means it's the first time she will be separated from her (beloved, supportive,etc as in why does it matter to her that they are separated) sisters) -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war (do they live in Antartica?). Her fifthteen-year-old sister is given an opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. Their oldest sister joins the military to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves. (I don't think you need to include here which sister does what. You can just say, one sister is off to do this, the other is off to do that, etc. It cuts it down. I would also lead with the one that joins the military so it ties into your mention of there being a civil war in Antartica)
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death (when you said her parent's world-changing experiment, it made it seem like both parents were alive. this is a little confusing), he expects help finding the experiment's (what experiment?) missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.
 
Set in a futuristic Antarctica, this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
I totally understand how you are trying to connect all these pieces, but it seems a bit jumbled. If the story is told through the perspective of all the daughters, I'm not sure opening your query focusing on one daughter is the best choice. Maybe start with setting up the super interesting setting, then go into what's at stake for the dad and the girls as a whole. You could even focus on the father more and not go into so much detail about what each girl is doing, say something like "Antartica's second civil war has caused the close-knit sisters to be apart for the first time in their lives, each setting off to contribute to the war effort in their own way" something like that. I also don't really understand what the dad is trying to do, what is the experiment? What does he hope to accomplish with it? Totally just suggestions. Your book sounds amazing by the way!


#8 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 07 March 2018 - 12:52 PM

Thank you! And great points. I may end up going back to the query being from the dad's POV like I did in my first try...lots to think about. Thank you again!

#9 ryooan

ryooan

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 6 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting, unagented
  • LocationUS Midwest

Posted 07 March 2018 - 05:11 PM

 

Try #2:

 

 

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters and the last to know she's being sent away for the summer. Most importantly, the last hope for her parent's (maybe just father's if Skye's mother is dead?) world-changing experiment (the experiment is a little vague throughout. Can you be more specific about what the experiment is or why Skye's parents tried to do it?). Skye learns she'll spend the summer studying at a monastery which houses a fortune teller with the answers they need. (Can you be more specific about the answers? Why do they need a fortune teller for the experiment? What's preventing the experiment from being completed?)
 
Not only is Skye leaving, but every sister will be separated for the first time in their lives -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war. Her fifthteen-year-old sister is given an opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. Their oldest sister joins the military to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves. (I agree with the previous commenter that you should be more brief about the other sisters. I don't think you need to waste valuable query space on their ages or whether they're oldest, etc. Here's an attempt at rewriting this paragraph:
 
Not only will it be Skye's first time off on her own, but the first time the sisters have been apart -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war. One of her sister's must travel across the Wall to the East, into enemy territory. Another must join the military to financially support the family. And one runs off to join an underground gang of smugglers and thieves. (that's what I understood the second oldest to be doing, but maybe clarify it if that's not correct)).
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death, he expects help finding the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered (at stake). The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.
 
Set in a futuristic Antarctica, this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
[Short Bio]
 
Thank you for your time and consideration.

 

 

You might be better served not even mentioning the other sister's stories. They're interesting, but right now we just get a tiny taste of what each sister is doing. It might be more compelling to learn more about what struggles and challenges Skye will face with the fortune teller. I think it is better to focus on one of the POV sisters instead of the dad like you did in your first draft, so I definitely think this version is better. Focusing on one sister might be something to play with and to see if that produces more excitement. I'm not positive on that though, as the other sisters do sound like they will have interesting adventures.

 

One other thing, is the father the antagonist here? If he is, is it supposed to be a secret? If you stick closer to Skye's perspective in the query maybe the last paragraph could be more about her suspicion that her father doesn't care about them and is just using her and her sisters for whatever it is he wants to do? And it might be more emotional if your closing line is her worrying about ever seeing her family again. It would be more personal that way.

 

I do like what you have going on so far, the story does sound cool and enticing. I think you can really help it come across more clearly and more impact if you clarify a few things and perhaps narrow the focus a bit.

 

Just some thoughts to consider, hopefully they're helpful to you in some way!



#10 PureZhar3

PureZhar3

    Veteran Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 385 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Midwest

Posted 07 March 2018 - 05:42 PM

 

Try #2:

 

 

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters and the last to know she's being sent away for the summer. Most importantly, the last hope for her parent's world-changing experiment. Skye learns she'll spend the summer studying at a monastery which houses a fortune teller with the answers they need. ​I really like the first half of this hook, but I think the last sentence detracts from it. Maybe make it the first sentence of the next paragraph.
 
Not only is Skye leaving, but every sister will be separated for the first time in their lives -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war ​not 100% sure how these two things are related. Her fifthteen​ fifteen?-year-old sister is given an opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. ​you're losing me... Their oldest sister joins the military to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves.​ You need to be clearer about what's going on. Maybe try organizing the paragraph something like this: Every summer, Skye's parents exploit their daughters to gain needed resources. The oldest sister joins the military to provide financial support. The second oldest will stay at home to infiltrate an underground gang of smugglers to build connections. The third sister will travel across the Wall into enemy territory to garner contacts. And Skye herself will spend the summer studying at a monastery, spying on a fortune teller to gain knowledge. 
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death, he expects help finding the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. ​again, could be cleaner. If you go with the previously suggested paragraph setting for the second paragraph, then this paragraph could be more about what the experiment is for. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again. ​Each of the sisters' summers will be used to help finish their father's experiment. He has been searching for a way to produce magic since his wife died, and if he succeeds, the war that is about to erupt between the two halves of Antarctica can be ended. Yet.. *ending stakes*/
Set in a futuristic Antarctica, this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
[Short Bio]
 
Thank you for your time and consideration.

 

Interesting! I think I understood the general gist of the query; however, the information is not presented in the cleanest order. I suggested a way of organizing information that I think could produce a very tight query, while still allowing you to focus on the family as a whole. Hope it helps!


If you have time, I'd appreciate it if you took a look at my query: http://agentquerycon...-realismsci-fi/


#11 JDSmith

JDSmith

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 81 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting, emerging
  • LocationUS West Coast
  • Publishing Experience:I have finished my first novel and am currently figuring out the publishing process in hopes to one day be published.

Posted 08 March 2018 - 06:21 PM

 

Try #2:

 

 

Thirteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four daughters and the last to know she's being sent away for the summer. Most importantly, the last hope for her parent's world-changing experiment. Skye learns she'll spend the summer studying at a monastery which houses a fortune teller with the answers they need. (This sentence is confusing. I feel out of the loop.)
 
Not only is Skye leaving, but every sister will be separated for the first time in their lives -- just when Antarctica is threatened by a second civil war. Her fifthteen-year-old sister is given an opportunity of a lifetime, but only if she travels across the Wall to the East. The enemy side. Their oldest sister joins the military to financially support the family. And the second oldest is left home to wreak havoc with an underground gang of Western smugglers and thieves.
 
Skye's dad sees opportunity in each of their situations. Although he’s neglected them since their mother's death, he expects help finding the experiment's missing pieces -- the magic his wife sought. But when the war starts, Antarctica's fate and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. The family separates at a tumultuous time, and the Ivoroconos may never reunite again.
 
(I feel like this jumps around too much. I'm left very confused about what is going on. I understand that the unique part of the story is the four different points of view, but the querry needs to feel like we're talking about the absolute main character. Maybe arange it so all four are the main character if that's how the story is. "The four are ___" "The daughters __" and talk about their situation once sentence per daughter. If Skye is the main character center it around her. I'm also unsure about what the "failed experiment" is. It comes out of nowhere. I know you know what's going on, but keep in mind that the agent doesn't, so word it correctly.) 
 
Set in a futuristic Antarctica (Maybe hint at this earlier on?), this story unfolds through the eyes of each Ivorocono daughter. A Low Fantasy YA complete at 97,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like Louisa May Alcott's LITTLE WOMEN met Leigh Bardugo's SIX OF CROWS. 
 
[Short Bio]
 
Thank you for your time and consideration.

 

So yeah, I think you need to rework this a bit. Nothing you can't do :)


I'd really appreciate help with my query: Iris Mjolnir Spawn of War

 

First 250 words here: Woooo

 

Write on!


#12 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 12 March 2018 - 08:53 AM

Thank you all for the help!! I'll keep all of this in mind for the next draft!

#13 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 17 August 2019 - 03:24 PM

Okay, it has been some time, but I am back to seek feedback on draft 3! Any and all assistance is appreciated and I will return the favor by critiquing your work!

 

 

Fourteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four sisters, last to know she is being sent away, and the last hope for her dad's experiment. Her dad is obsessed with unearthing a mythical magic. He sends Skye to study at a monastery where a seer has answers to help his experiment. Skye has other plans. She hopes to defy her father and avoid the seer at any cost.

 

Not only is Skye leaving, but each of her beloved sisters are separated -- in the midst of war. One sister receives a rare opportunity to pursue her singing dreams, but only if she travels east to enemy territory. Another is left home to wreak havoc as a skilled menace and thief. The oldest sister is forced to join the military to financially support the family.

 

Skye's dad sees opportunity in each situation. He has neglected them since their mother's death, but demands help finding the experiment's missing pieces. When the war starts, avoiding a mysterious seer and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. War, prejudices, and a deadly epidemic threaten to destroy everything. Skye may never see her sisters again.

 

An afro-centric YA low fantasy complete at 94,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like “Little Women” meets “The Powerpuff Girls.” It may appeal to readers who enjoy multiple POV stories like “Six of Crows.” 

 

Thank you for your time and consideration.



#14 Bibliophyl

Bibliophyl

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 93 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Northeast

Posted 18 August 2019 - 07:58 AM

Thanks for stopping by my query!

 

Fourteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four sisters, last to know she is being sent away, and the last hope for her dad's experiment. Her dad is obsessed with unearthing a mythical magic. [we might need more reasoning behind this quest for magic. Will it give him some particular ability or power? Why is this so important?] He sends Skye to study at a monastery where a seer has answers to help his experiment. Skye has other plans. She hopes to defy her father and avoid the seer at any cost. I think we need to know why she doesn't want to help--we don't have enough background yet to understand why this magic is a bad thing and why she would resist. 

 

Not only is Skye leaving, but each of her beloved sisters are separated -- in the midst of war. One sister receives a rare opportunity to pursue her singing dreams, but only if she travels east to enemy territory. Another is left home to wreak havoc as a skilled menace and thief. The oldest sister is forced to join the military to financially support the family.

 

Skye's dad sees opportunity in each situation. He has neglected them since their mother's death, but demands help finding the experiment's missing pieces. When the war starts, avoiding a mysterious seer and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered [this sentence doesn't quite make sense]. War, prejudices, and a deadly epidemic threaten to destroy everything. Skye may never see her sisters again. [I think we need to know what she has to accomplish in order to fix the situation. Right now she doesn't seem like a very active protagonist--all we know is that she's put into a situation she doesn't want to be in, but we don't know what action she has to take.]

 

An afro-centric YA low fantasy complete at 94,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like “Little Women” meets “The Powerpuff Girls.” It may appeal to readers who enjoy multiple POV stories like “Six of Crows.”  Just a formatting thing, but I think all book titles, including comps, are supposed to be capitalized. 

 

I hope this was helpful! I think we need a little more clarity and focus around the core conflict. It's a little vague as is ("mythical magic" " experiment's missing pieces" etc.). I just don't have a great sense of what is actually going on. I know it's hard to boil down a multi-POV story to a query like this. Good luck!



#15 London C

London C

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 60 posts
  • Literary Status:unagented
  • LocationUS Midwest

Posted 18 August 2019 - 05:02 PM

Hi Janeald,

 

Thanks for the comments on my query. 

 

I'm not sure about the order of version 3. Continuing to lead with Skye, I think you need to set-up the threat more in the first paragraph, something like a combination of paragraphs 1 and 3, then move into how that specifically impacts Skye and her sisters. And, as Bibliophyle notes, it should give the reader some sense of what Skye and her sisters have to do to fight that threat. 

 

Right now, this reads almost as if the father is the narrative center, rather than the sisters. I don't have much sense of why the sisters other than Skye are doing what they're doing and how they're interacting—is this four different storylines that converge late in the novel, or are they interacting as they navigate their different places in the world? 

 

There are a lot of interesting elements here, so I suspect the novel is intriguing. It just needs to be a bit clearer on the page. Good luck!


——————

My latest query is here. I appreciate reciprocal critiques


#16 CarterT

CarterT

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 107 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationCanada

Posted 19 August 2019 - 08:35 AM

Going to echo a little bit what the others are saying in that I think you have too much information about everybody other than Skye. We know about her sister's dreams, but not about hers. We know what her sisters are doing...but what is she up to? We know about her dad's plans (loosely), but how about hers?

 

If Skye is going to be the focus of your query, MAKE her the focus. Don't talk about what other people are doing or thinking, unless it's 'from Skye's perspective' so to speak. Right now she seems like a passenger in the story instead of the driving force. Now, even is she is just one of multiple POV, the query should be mostly about her (even though the book isn't, exactly). With the length a query is supposed to be, you don't have the words to talk about the others. 

 

I think you start off on the right track in sentence one, but then it becomes about her dad more than her, then on to her sisters, then the world at large, but it doesn't come back to her. So, dig into her plotline more, and do it from her perspective. You talk about the seer and the monastery, so give us a bit about what she's doing to get out of that mess. And then, what's her turning point going to be? When does she make a choice she can't go back from? Her 'or else' moment to end the query with. 



#17 Anna.k

Anna.k

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 119 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting, emerging, unagented
  • LocationUS Midwest
  • Publishing Experience:Working on it!

Posted 19 August 2019 - 02:52 PM

Okay, it has been some time, but I am back to seek feedback on draft 3! Any and all assistance is appreciated and I will return the favor by critiquing your work!

 

 

Fourteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four sisters, last to know she is being sent away, and the last hope for her dad's experiment. (hmm, interesting) Her dad is obsessed with unearthing a mythical magic. (What's mythical magic???) He sends Skye to study at a monastery (But isn't she a girl? Lol) where a seer has answers to help his experiment.(I still don't know what the experiment/mythical magic is...) Skye has other plans. She hopes to defy her father and avoid the seer at any cost. (Yey for Skye, but this could be reworded and made stronger. I.e, Skye has other plans. Defy her father and escape...)

 

Not only is Skye leaving, but each of her beloved sisters are separated -- in the midst of war. (What war now? Confused about the world/time setting of this story) One sister receives a rare opportunity to pursue her singing dreams, but only if she travels east to enemy territory. Another is left home to wreak havoc as a skilled menace and thief. The oldest sister is forced to join the military to financially support the family. (This seems like backstory, and I'm not sure what purpose it serves, detracting from Skye completely...)

 

Skye's dad sees opportunity in each situation. He has neglected them since their mother's death, but demands help finding the experiment's missing pieces. When the war starts, avoiding a mysterious seer and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. War, prejudices, and a deadly epidemic threaten to destroy everything. Skye may never see her sisters again. (There's a lot of stuff here, and it all seems kind of thrown together. It's confusing. I don't know what planet we're on, what the experiment is, what magic is involved, what genre it is, etc. Pick a main theme; If Skye is the main character, stick to her struggle with her father using her and the looming backdrop of war. I'm not even sure you need to insert all the sisters even if it IS a multiple POV. It might just add to the confusion.)

 

An afro-centric YA low fantasy complete at 94,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like “Little Women” meets “The Powerpuff Girls.” It may appeal to readers who enjoy multiple POV stories like “Six of Crows.” (This doesn't seem like an appropriate comp title for the story presented....)

 

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Hi Janeald

Interested in the potential here esp since I love Little Women lol. We just need a lot more specifics and clarity.

Please take a look at my query when you can, thanks!!

http://agentquerycon...d-2-ya-fantasy/



#18 hermitage

hermitage

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 169 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Northeast
  • Publishing Experience:Some academic, none in fiction.

Posted 19 August 2019 - 09:25 PM



Okay, it has been some time, but I am back to seek feedback on draft 3! Any and all assistance is appreciated and I will return the favor by critiquing your work!

 

 

Fourteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono is always last. The last of four sisters, last to know she is being sent away, and the last hope for her dad's experiment. Her dad is obsessed with unearthing a mythical magic. He sends Skye to study at a monastery where a seer has answers to help his experiment. Skye has other plans. She hopes to defy her father and avoid the seer at any cost. [This paragraph feels a little "choppy," i.e. comprised mostly of short sentences that don't flow together very easily. Also, I'm wondering where and when we are? Present day? What country?]

 

Not only is Skye leaving, but each of her beloved sisters are separated -- in the midst of war. [What kind of war? Who is fighting? Obviously we don't need the whole history here, but at least just a few words to let us know what's happening? Is it a civil war? A fantasy war? Etc.] One sister receives a rare opportunity to pursue her singing dreams, but only if she travels east to enemy territory. Another is left home to wreak havoc as a skilled menace and thief. The oldest sister is forced to join the military to financially support the family.

 

Skye's dad sees opportunity in each situation. He has neglected them since their mother's death, but demands help finding the experiment's missing pieces. When the war starts, avoiding a mysterious seer and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. [I don't know if this works grammatically. Are all these things that are "endangered"?] War, prejudices, and a deadly epidemic threaten to destroy everything. Skye may never see her sisters again.

 

An afro-centric YA low fantasy [What is the fantasy part of this?] complete at 94,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like “Little Women” meets “The Powerpuff Girls.” It may appeal to readers who enjoy multiple POV stories like “Six of Crows.” [You might want to approach your "comp" titles more in terms of what current authors write to your target audience.]

 

Thank you for your time and consideration.

 

This is a hard one. Right now, I feel like I can't get a clear picture of what's happening in your book. You're trying to tell us the trajectories of five characters (the four sisters, and the dad), and that might be taxing your ability to make things understandable. I came to this the hard way (the very, very hard way), but I think it's easier to describe one character's story in a bit of detail than trying to keep track of multiple characters within a 200-230-word pitch.

 

Or in other words I think it's better to describe a few ideas in a somewhat fleshed-out, understandable way than to try to squeeze in as many ideas as you're taking on here. I feel myself bouncing around between things that I don't really grasp: a war, an experiment, and the impact of both on four sisters with diverging paths. If you want to tell us about the experiment, for example, how about maybe telling us what it's actually trying to accomplish? Does the dad want super powers or something? Is he trying to talk to ghosts? I just have no idea, so it's hard to get hooked. And if I knew what place and time we were in, and what it was being fought over, it would be much easier to relate to this idea of a war.

 

I think at a basic level we want to know at least what kind of person the main character is, what she wants to achieve, what problems/antagonists are in her way, and what kind of story this conflict will drive. 



#19 janeald

janeald

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 97 posts
  • Literary Status:just starting
  • LocationUS Southeast
  • Publishing Experience:I have only published journalistic work.

Posted 19 August 2019 - 09:32 PM

Thank you to everyone who responded! I appreciate the great feedback!



#20 mindy24601

mindy24601

    New Member

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 52 posts
  • Literary Status:emerging, unagented
  • LocationUS Northeast

Posted 21 August 2019 - 03:08 PM

Okay, it has been some time, but I am back to seek feedback on draft 3! Any and all assistance is appreciated and I will return the favor by critiquing your work!

 

 

Fourteen-year-old Skye Ivorocono maybe just "Skye"? sounds a bit like a Mary-Sue name, which isn't the best way to start is always last. The last of four sisters, the last to know she is being sent away, and the last hope for her dad's experiment. Her dad is obsessed with unearthing a mythical magic. He , whosends Skye to study at a monastery where a seer has promises answers to help with his mystical experiment. Skye has other plans. She hopes to defy her father and avoid the seer at any cost.sounds a little juvenile, consider ramping up your language and sentence structure

 

Not only is Skye leaving, but each of her beloved sisters are separated -- in the midst of war. One sister receives a rare opportunity to pursue her singing dreams, but only if she travels east to enemy territory. Another is left home to wreak havoc as a skilled menace and thief. The oldest sister is forced to join the military to financially support the family. 

 

Skye's dad sees opportunity in each situation. unclear how? how do any of these relate? He has neglected them since their mother's death, but demands help finding the experiment's missing pieces. which are who? test subjects? the sisters? When the war starts, avoiding a mysterious seer and a failed experiment aren't the only things endangered. War, prejudices, and a deadly epidemic threaten to destroy everything. Skye may never see her sisters again.

 

An afro-centric YA low not sure "low fantasy" is a widely-recognised genre...maybe light fantasy? contemporary fantasy? fantasy complete at 94,000 words, THE FOUR IVOROCONO GIRLS is like “Little Women” meets “The Powerpuff Girls.” It may appeal to readers who enjoy multiple POV stories like “Six of Crows.” A bit of a tall order to use this as your comp...can you think of anything a bit more recent?

 

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Good luck! I'd really try to focus on snappy, catchy language and making everything less vague. Your story sounds a little generic at this point. 






0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users